In looking for a place to start with American women writers I decided the best place to begin would be to read the books from my own shelves (which I will do), however I also thought it would be interesting to read all of the Pulitzer Prize winning novels or short story collections written by women. There have been thirty women who have won the prize since 1918, from Edith Wharton in 1921 to this year’s winner, Donna Tartt. I have read several of the novels including The Goldfinch and most of the recent female winners, but there are more that I haven’t read and some that I haven’t even heard of. The Able McLaughlins by Margaret Wilson is one of the novels that was previously unknown to me.
It won the prize in 1924 and is set just after the Civil War in Iowa. The McLaughlin family are Scottish immigrants who left Glasgow to escape their cramped home (they have 11 children), to own land and to make a better living than they have in Scotland. They live in a farming community of other Scottish families who all support and encourage each other. When the novel opens the McLaughlin’s oldest son Wully has just returned from the war and plans to marry a neighbor girl, Chirstie McNair. Despite a previous understanding, she won’t have anything to do with him when he rides over to see her. Of course, he’s hurt but he’s mostly perplexed and persists until he finds out the reason she’s rejected him and the terrible secret she’s been keeping. The rest of the novel tells of the repercussions the secret has not only on Wully and Chirstie, but on the entire community.
The Able McLaughlins is not a sophisticated novel, but it’s a definite page turner. I found myself racing through it, wanting to know how Wully and Chirstie would come out and if the secret would be revealed. Compared to The Age of Innocence, which won the prize just a couple of years before, it seems terribly melodramatic and doesn’t have the nuanced characterizations that Wharton writes so beautifully. It has lots of panache and vigor and the descriptions of the pioneer life are riveting, but I’m not really surprised this novel has fallen off our reading radar – it’s in no way a classic and has a troubling theme and a bleak view of women. In 1936 Wilson published a sequel to the novel, The Law and the McLaughlins, and I’ve thought about requesting it through ILL, but I’m not sure it would be worth the $6.
I’d like to read at least one female Pulitzer Prize winner this summer – it will probably be Willa Cather or Edna Ferber. I haven’t decided if I’ll re-read the works I’ve already read like Gone With the Wind (probably not) and To Kill a Mockingbird so for now I’ll stick to reading the ones that are new to me.
Have you read any of the Pulitzers won by women? You can see a list of all the winners (male and female) here.
5 thoughts on “Pulitzer Project: The Able McLaughlins by Margaret Wilson”
Hi Anblolyn, I read The Shipping News which I remember liking very much. Also One Thousand Acres by Jane Smiley, though I don’t think I liked it as well. I didn’t go all the way back to the beginning of the list, but I have read many books by Edith Wharton and Willa Cather. What an interesting reading project. I can’t wait to hear about more of the books you read from the list. And I am so happy Donna Tartt won the Pulitzer for The Goldfinch!
I also really liked The Shipping News so that might be one that I re-read. I was so pleased that Donna Tartt won – it was kind of surprising, but well deserved!
I’ve read The Shipping News too, also One of Ours, To Kill a Mockingbird, Color Purple, The Optimist’s Daughter. I’ve also read lots of Wharton and Cather and all of Updike’s Rabbit books, but he wasn’t a girly, in fact his are the only books by a male author which I have read on the list, I must do better!
I’ve never read Updike except for The Witches of Eastwick, which I felt lukewarm about, but I’d definitely try more of his work. I think One of Ours will be next as I love Cather.
I am reading every Pulitzer winning novel in order, and just finished The Able McLaughlins. While I agree with you that it lacks the nuance and depth of The Age of Innocence, I still found it a really beautiful story that celebrates a simple life and the simple, human goodness that can come with it. I actually liked it better than One of Ours, which I thought was much weaker than Cather’s other work.